The movie "A Room with a View" based on the novel of E.M Forster takes place in Italy and England. The movie is about a young girl named Lucy Honeychurch and her cousin/chaperone Charlotte Barlette, on their first visit to Florence, Italy. During their visit, they had the opportunity to meet Mr. Emerson and his son George Emerson, the sisters, Misses Alans, and Miss Lavish, the novelist with a sense of adventure.
The tourist vs. traveler concept represented in Jamaica Kincaid's, A Small Place, also takes part in this movie. The different characters represent different types of tourist and travelers.
The main character, Lucy
along with her cousin Charlotte represents for instance the concept of tourist,
during their first visit to Florence. The first thing that Charlotte says
when they are in their hotel room is: "This is not what we were led to
expect". This quote represents the expectation of the tourist first
experience in a new place. As in Kincaid’s essays, the tourist did not
have any idea what to expect, they did not care. Both, Lucy and Charlotte
were upset because they did not have a proper view in their room, and this
represents the superficiality of the tourist. In contrast to Mr. Emerson
and his son George Emerson, who were experienced travelers, were they did not
mind to switch rooms with them. Mr.
Emerson says: "I don't care to see what's outside; my vision is
within".
Lucy Honeychurch gets
transformed in the movie from a tourist to a travel. On her first car
ride in Florence, driven by an Italian, Mr. Beebs, he asks Lucy “So, Miss
Honeychurch, you're traveling? As a student of art? And she responded “I'm a
tourist". He then responded: "We residents sometimes pity you
poor tourist not a little". This quote is similar to the argument in
Kincaid's essays, especially when she is describing the tourist first car ride
in Antigua, were they are seeing new things that they do not understand.
Lucy experiences a transformation
from tourist to traveler. Miss Lavish,
who is also a traveler herself, states that Lucy is : " The young English
girl transformed by Italy" . Lucy gets transformed from a
tourist to a traveler, when she embraces her own internal journey, which in
this case is defined by love. One cannot be a traveler without being a tourist
first.
Jamaica Kincaid maybe would
have responded to the British women in a similar way as in her essays.
But maybe, Kincaid could understand that the expectation of a tourist is
to see places, things in the expedited fashion, and have a glimpse of something
unknown. Thus, only from the inner experience the tourist can be
transformed to a traveler.
I liked it the way that you established the relation between Kincaid and the movie.
ReplyDeleteYou explained very well the difference between a tourist and the traveler. Good job!
ReplyDeleteI also noted the transformation os Lucy from a tourist to a traveler. Nice post.
ReplyDeleteI always thought of Lucy as a tourist all the way up to the very end. I hadn't seen it that way. It is true that at the very end, she becomes more interested in things a traveler might find intriguing.
ReplyDeleteThe transformation from tourist to traveler is the main idea of the story. Good Analysis!
ReplyDelete